The quest asked for 3 of each quest item while only 1 of each was being handed in.
- Open the server QuestObjective config.
- For the 3rd quest items (Flame of Death Beam Knight, Horn of Hell Maine, Feather of Phoenix of Darkness) change the required count from 3 to 1, or hand in 3 of each.
- Reload the quest files and talk to the NPC again.